What You Can Learn from Casual Dining

David Blackburn has been in the foodservice business his entire adult life. Since 1979, the McAlister’s Deli franchisee has cataloged more than 25 years of experience in the casual-dining sector, spending 16 of those as regional vice president of operations at O’Charley’s.

Blackburn now owns and operates 23 McAlister’s Deli units across Tennessee, Mississippi, and Missouri.

He attributes his success in the quick-service sector largely to his casual-dining experience and expertise, from which he brings a focus on high levels of customer service and particular attention to staff training.

Blackburn discusses how franchisees can leverage these tactics to build quick-service success.

1. Find opportunities to engage

When I worked in the casual-dining sector, there was a focus on creating more opportunities to truly engage with the customer. This translates into the very thing that sets McAlister’s Deli apart, and that is our table service.

For a fast-casual concept, there is usually only one opportunity to engage with the customer: at the register. You’ll try to get as much dialogue in that situation as you can, but this is a short-timed affair.

At McAlister’s, we strive to engage with the customer three additional times: when bringing the food to the table; when refilling drinks and pre-bussing the table; and when proposing the idea of dessert.

These actions might be associated more strongly with casual dining, but it’s the engagement and service we are seeking to improve.

These additional engagement opportunities aren’t just for selling product; they are for servicing, too. By offering guests a refill, we have the chance to show the customers the appreciation we have for the business, and that’s really the core strength of the brand. Furthermore, we spend a lot of time training our staff on how to make the most of these instances with regards to service language—what things you want to say, or don’t want to say, to a guest at each particular moment.

Even with all those instances combined, it’s still a very short time span you actually get to interact with the customer, and we want to make the most of that.

2. Train your staff relentlessly

There are very few stones left unturned when it comes to staff training, even at the casual-dining level, and quick service is no different.

McAlister’s Deli has a very solid training program for employees and has specific training for each and every position, whether front or back of the house. The difference comes down to the commitment you have for the training and then, primarily, a relentless pursuit.

These are the individuals who run the engine on a daily basis. You need to ensure that it’s a good fit for your needs as a brand and that their specific needs are also met.

For instance, the training program we have for some of our younger managers has a big focus on courage—having enough courage to say to another employee, “That bread isn’t toasted enough,” or, “Only an hour more to go; let’s keep the good attitude going.” That can be really difficult for some people, but it’s a key factor in the daily success of the units.

The difference, again, comes down to a commitment to both your staff and your stores. You need to work on the character of the staff members, especially those who are managing other employees to the right and to the left.

It is always, and will always remain, a work in progress for your business. However, this type of commitment can take you from good to great.

3. Take advantage of your resources

A big challenge for me was leaving an environment that had a department for everything. When I left O’Charley’s, I had about 72 stores and what seemed like an infinite amount of resources available for every possible situation or scenario. From marketing and training to culinary, I had lots of people to help me troubleshoot.

When you’re a smaller franchisee, the lack of departments might seem alarming, but don’t cower in fear. The manpower might not be there, but the knowledge is, and there still are people to help.

I rely heavily on my multiunit supervisors at McAlister’s. These individuals are the experts in everything deli-related and can help me with anything I need in any department of the business. As a business owner, this is a relief. Only having to deal with one department, rather than several, is a time-saver.

4. Focus on relationships

As I mentioned, it’s no secret that in quick service, you have a very brief moment with the customer. Even with our additional engagement services, the 10 or 15 seconds that each instance provides might come out to a whole minute of interaction with the customer, and that could be on a good day.

Your staff must strive to make the most of the small window of one-on-one time they have with the guest. If one of your locations has regulars or a more talkative customer, try and keep the conversation going. Let other customers see it. This displays that atmosphere you’re striving to obtain.

McAlister’s Deli is a pretty savvy brand in and of itself. I studied it for about two years prior to getting the deal done, and it had everything I needed to make a successful transfer from one area to the other.

However, I brought in another casual-dining idea, the “alley rally,” which is a lineup that includes all the staff and any additional employees, such as managers. Here, we can talk about features, specials, and competitive challenges that you might have going to stimulate staff behaviors. It would also include focuses and goals for the day, week, or month.

I didn’t create or invent it, but it worked well in the casual sector and it can work for quick service, too. All of your staff benefits from these small meetings; more often than not, teaching the difference is the difference itself.

 

 

This article comes from QSR Magazine.com and can be found at http://www.qsrmagazine.com/franchising/what-you-can-learn-casual-dining?microsite=1703&utm_campaign=20130419&utm_source=jolt&utm_medium=email

What “The Walking Dead” can Teach us about Mystery Shopping!

AMC’s Easter Sunday Season 3 finale of mega-hit, “The Walking Dead”, the highest rated drama in the history of cable television, scored another ratings best when 12.4 million viewers tuned in, with 8.1 million viewers in the key 18-49 demographic. Not only is the show crazy popular, but there are some great mystery shopping tips you can pick up just from watching the example the characters set on the show.

So if you haven’t seen TWD, get your Netflix on and get caught up and come back to read this…but if you are a veteran, let’s go!

1. Walkers do not Make Great Mystery Shoppers.

What could be a worse model for a great mystery shopper than a walker? They draw attention to themselves, they are very predictable and they so obviously have only one thing on their mind. That’s like the total recipe for a bad shopper! Great shoppers are discreet and don’t stand out in the crowd. They have to act like normal people, not stereo-typed and predictable, and not obsessive about getting a look at a name tag or trying to remember all the departments to hit. A great shopper is cool, relaxed, ordinary,….and blends in. Also not a good idea to walk on the side of your foot, wear tattered clothes or attempt to eat anyone’s entrails during the shop…those may also give you away.

2. Only Take on the Assignments that You can Handle.

That poor Andrea…she was trying to save the whole world! She was in over her head for that assignment. She might have been more successful if she had started with a smaller project, but trying to keep Woodbury together and keep the prison safe was too much and she made some bad mistakes which ultimately made her an appetizer for Milton, and things went downhill from there. Not all projects are the same; and a great shopper works their way up to the more complex projects over time. There is a big difference between doing a quick service restaurant shop and doing a new home builder or education enrollment shop. If Andrea had maybe stuck to oil changes (and yes, we have plenty of those to request, please call scheduling!), she might have later been able to enjoy an upscale dining experience later on. But in her present state, she is no longer eligible for any future shops.

3. Follow Instructions!

How about that crazy Morgan shooting up that little town, all holed up in his building? He done lost his mind! But things might have been different if he had followed Rick’s instructions and got up at dawn with the walkie-talkie like Rick did, so Rick could have guided him to safety. Great mystery shoppers follow their directions to the letter, and call the scheduler to ask a question about anything that leaves them feeling unsure. That makes them successful, and ensures that the shop will go off as planned. So make sure you understand the directions and follow them closely. That way, you won’t go crazy, and you won’t drive your scheduler crazy!

4. Pay no Attention to the Lady in White!

Remember how Rick kept seeing Lori after she died? That wasn’t real. It was a distraction, in fact. As a great shopper, you pay attention to what matters to the client. If it’s not on the guidelines, don’t be distracted by it. For instance, if you are doing a dining shop and the client wants to know how long it took to get the food delivered, and if your entree was cooked properly, but is not interested in scoring desserts, don’t go there in your narrative…stick to writing about the entree. The analysis of the dessert may be written in superlative prose, but if the client is not interested in your thoughts on the dessert, you just wasted your time and some editor’s time, who will delete your review faster than Shane ran home to tell Lori that Rick was a goner and that they needed to immediately start shacking up for Carl’s sake!

5. Timing Matters.

Pay close attention to when a shop can begin and when it must be submitted by. Check the appropriate hours to do the shop. Timing matters. If you knew Phillip Blake back in the day, he was a pretty chill guy, with a nice wife and sweet daughter Penny. But today, the Governor has no wife, no daughter, no girl friend and no right eye! Plus now he literally is into finger food; just ask Merle. Timing matters.

A Tale of Two Brands

While traveling in February I experienced a sequence of events that so clearly contrasted a group of employees who naturally displayed superior customer service with another group of workers who have lost my personal business for their company for life.

I was traveling with my four children in England, and we had rented a car to drive from London to Stonehenge (and to visit HighClere Castle, site of Downton Abbey, but that’s another story!). We made a reservation with a major international car rental company that has more vowels than consonants in its name (and shares its name with a top tourist attraction in San Antonio, if you can “remember”).

On Sunday, we walked from our flat to the Central London branch that we had booked our car from and arrived at the scheduled time only to be told there were no cars available. But we had a reservation. She simply shrugged and said that that didn’t mean that she now had a car available. I asked if any other London offices had cars available, and she said that she was sorry, but everyone is out. The best she could do is honor our rate for the next day.

Well, with no other choices left, we scrapped our Sunday plans and reinvented new ones. We also ditched our Monday agenda to return to the car rental office the next morning.

This time, there was a car as promised. To give credit due, we were given a token apology for the rebooking by that day’s agent before leaving the office.

After exploring the mysteries of Stonehenge and pretending to be heirs of HighClere Castle, we stopped for a quick pub lunch at Windsor on our way back to London. Not long after we got back on the road and entered the M4 highway, I felt a gradual, then more demanding, tug on the steering wheel to the left. I took the first available exit, pulling off the road into the Marriott Windsor/Heathrow Hotel parking lot. Here we were, in a foreign country, with no cell phone, and a flat tire.

I walked into the lobby of the Marriott and approached the concierge, who greeted me with a warm smile. I explained our situation and asked if it was possible that I might be able to use the phone to call the designated roadside assistance company. He asked if I minded if he made the call for me and asked for the paperwork. Smiling still, he then invited the children to sit and relax in the lobby.

He explained the situation in phone calls to both the rental car company and to the roadside assistance company. He then told us he was told that it would be up to two hours before the mechanic arrived (which he disgustedly felt was ridiculous), and invited us to relax in the hotel lounge. He promised that he would personally come and get us when the mechanic arrived.

Unfortunately hours came and went, and no mechanic. The concierge made several phone calls back, asking where the mechanic was, complaining that there were children stranded here with me. Still no mechanic.

Eventually at 10pm, five and a half hours after pulling into the parking lot…the concierge’s shift was over and he was going home. He called one more time, and they told him “within the hour”. He said to me he had made arrangements for us to stay at the hotel overnight if we needed or wanted to, at a rate that was very fair indeed. He brought waters and sodas to the children. And he introduced me to the security manager, who would help us out if need be after he left.

Am I clear that we were not even guests of this hotel?

When the mechanic finally showed, going on midnight (we pulled in to the hotel at 4:30pm), he changed the tire and then reported that the two back tires were bald. The security manager explained that it was illegal to drive with bald tires in Britain, and that those tires could cost us over $3,000 in fines if pulled over and written tickets. The mechanic agreed, but said my issue was with the rental car agency, which was true.

The security manager asked if I minded if he called the rental car agency for us, and after getting my permission, he made the call. He tried to explain to the rental company that he couldn’t understand how they could have leased us an illegal car, and that it was absurd to ask us to drive the car back to the rental agency.

I then took the receiver and tried to lay out our options. The easiest solution was to take our chances and get the car back to Heathrow Airport and go from there, so we did. At the airport, we were now dealing with all new employees who knew nothing of our painful odyssey. So I had to explain everything over again. The sales agent had to go talk to the manager who….knew nothing of our situation. The manager offered to give us a 20 pound credit on our bill and remove the drop charge for bringing the car back to a different location. (Say what??! After all that you are actually thinking of adding a drop-charge to our bill???)

I respectfully, but firmly, explained that the rental car company had, in my estimation, an obligation to get me and my children back to London, at least to their London location where we rented the car (now spoken by me at 1:30am).  The manager politely disagreed, and refused my request to send us back to London in a cab.

What were our options? Paying for a cab ourselves, at around $80 on top of everything else? Taking the Tube (subway)? Already stopped running for the night. “Well you can take the night bus…it’s just a two block walk and although there are 25 stops between here and where you need to go, it will get you there.” Gee, thanks alot. We stumbled into our flat at 3:00am, nearly 12 hours since the tire went flat.

What is the end result? I will never rent from the consonant-challenged rental car company again. I will tell everyone in my network and on Facebook about how uncaring ALL of the employees were that I encountered. And my story will pass down the line.

I am also telling everyone about the wonderful service and support given to me and my children by the employees of the Marriott Windsor/Heathrow. What fantastic human beings, and clearly part of a corporate culture that values relationships, even with non-customers like we were that day. Trust me, if this is who Marriott is as a corporate culture, they are now the first place for us to look for a hotel. And I will recommend to many  of my internationally traveling friends that they stay at the Marriott Windsor/Heathrow when traveling in London and looking for a great place to stay by Heathrow Airport or near Windsor.

The point is, not only does customer service matter, it leave scars…good scars and bad scars. My kids will never forget how indifferent the car rental brand was to us; they will also never forget how kind, helpful and understanding the Marriott employees were. How many people will they influence and touch with this story over their lifetime?

This is why a company like Shoppers’ Critique International exists…to help management understand how their brand and employees are perceived by the buying public. Not every company uses customer intelligence tools to find out…maybe some are having budget troubles, maybe some just don’t get it or care. Who knows with the car rental company that we rented our last vehicle from. But Marriott gets it. Well done, Marriott, and thank you for your outstanding customer service. You have made lifetime fans of your brand. The car rental company? Yeah,….not so much. In fact, not ever again.

 

It IS a Wonderful Life When You Know What Your Customer Thinks

Were you recently reminded of those days of an “Old-Fashion Christmas”? You know, like in the days of “It’s a Wonderful Life”, where everything was smaller and easier for us to get our arms around? Back then, many store owners, managers and clerks knew their customers and what was important to them. They didn’t need to survey the customer’s opinions or mystery shop their operations. They would just ask Abner or Miriam what they thought as they rung their purchase up at the till. And they delivered personalized service.

Wow! How far away that seems in today’s over-sized and mega-competitive world! From retail to restaurants, apartment leasing to automotive sales, everything seems so much more competitive.

The good news about conducting business nowadays is that it is, in fact, a bigger world…a much larger marketplace with room for multiple vendors and millions of customers who can be targeted for the sales of computers, cell phones, steaks, full-efficient SUVs and countless other products and services. The downside: how do you maintain the feel and information flow of that 1946 Bedford Falls, NY customer connection of “It’s a Wonderful Life” in 2013 Manhattan, NY?

Today, it requires tools. Precise metrics for measuring key aspects of the customer service experience. Mechanisms for gauging customer loyalty, based on the experiences, impressions and halos, both positive and negative, received through interacting with front line sales attendants. Companies need the means to determine if corporate policy is being implemented, and even if so, to assess whether those policies are impacting the customer in the way that was anticipated, procuring the intended emotional response or not. In an era where Z-MOT, or the zero moment of truth, reigns over the first encounter, it is even more essential to measure, review, adjust and re-measure every channel by which business connects with consumers.

At the crossroads of measured performance and real, relevant data is where a customer intelligence company like Shoppers’ Critique International stands, fully utilizing its 40+ years of experience in data gathering, assessment and performance enhancement feedback to close the gaps between business and customers. It’s not one methodology; not one cookie cutter solution. Our solutions involve a personal look at the unique relationship between a company and the audience that it seeks to please, its customers. If your business isn’t taking advantage of the many assets and tools that Shoppers’ Critique can provide, chances are you might not really know what sort of emotional responses you are truly generating. Cost-effective, easy to implement: it IS a wonderful life, when you know for sure the specific impressions that you are imprinting on your customer base. This powerful knowledge supplies the competitive edge for leading brands to adjust their operations and assets, consistently now reaching that group in the manner that they always intended while maximizing market share and revenue potential. That’s powerful; that’s a Bedford Falls philosophy and an action plan for a 21st century.

We here at Shoppers’ Critique International wish everyone a wonderful and prosperous New Year! Hope to see you around the Falls sometime soon!

Shoppers’ Critique Delivers to Kids House of Seminole, Inc.

(Longwood, FL – December 25, 2012)  Shoppers’ Critique International, one of America’s largest and oldest customer intelligence agencies once again rallied its employees to deliver a very Merry Christmas to one of Seminole County’s needy families through Kids House of Seminole, Inc. Hundreds of dollars worth of new clothing and toys were donated by generous SCI employees for the fifth consecutive year.

“One of our former account supervisors, Sandy Tenore, had a daughter who is a caseworker with Kids House,” explained Shoppers’ Critique General Manager Sharon Rice. “When she shared information with us and we read the heart-breaking stories about the families that Kids House reaches out to, we felt like we had to do something to get involved.”

For more than a decade, Kids House has been a safe and caring place where child victims of abuse can find compassionate care and healing. In the last fiscal year, Kids House helped heal 2,256 children. Their mission is to prevent child abuse and to aid child abuse victims and families by providing coordinated services in a safe, child-friendly environment, from report and investigation, through treatment and resolution.

Each year Kids House hosts a large holiday party for nearly 300 children and their families. Each child receives a special gift from their wish list and is invited to participate in crafts, games, face painting and have their picture taken with Santa Claus. Additionally, about 30 special families are selected each year and are provided with a complete holiday – including decorations and gifts. SCI has sponsored one of these families each of the last five years.

“They (Kids House) supply us with a specific list that each of the kids wished for in our adopted family. This year we have a little boy and little girl, and we will be donating toys, games, books and clothes that they asked for,” continued Rice.

Kids House is located in Sanford, Florida, the county seat of Seminole County, which is also home to Shoppers’ Critique International.

-30-

About Shoppers’ Critique International

Shoppers’ Critique International is one of America’s largest and oldest customer intelligence companies. Based in suburban Orlando, Florida since 1972, the customer service capital of the world, SCI has developed a legacy of providing the nation’s top corporations with reliable and insightful measurement metrics, analysis and assessment and re-directional training across dozens of industries. A charter member of the Mystery Shopping Providers Association, Shoppers’ Critique captures the customer experience for its clients, delivering the highest quality, most credible information in a timely manner, as well as actionable solutions to maximize customer retention and revenue growth, providing an unparalleled return on investment.

 

Shoppers’ Critique International Announces 2012 Theme Park Super Six Winners

(Orlando, FL – November 20, 2012Shoppers’ Critique International, one of America’s largest and oldest customer intelligence companies, and the leading provider of consumer data to the theme park and attractions industry, has announced the 2012 Super Six winners as follows:

Northeast Region:         Canada’s Wonderland                      Cedar Fair Entertainment

Mid-Atlantic Region:      Dutch Wonderland                           Palace Entertainment

Southeast Region:          Legoland Florida                               Merlin Entertainments Group

Midwest Region:            Silver Dollar City                               Herschend Family Entertainment

Southwest Region:         Sea World San Diego                       Sea World Parks & Entertainment

Northwest Region:        Six Flags Discovery Kingdom           Six Flags Entertainment Corporation

The 2012 field features all first time winners, and the debut of winning parks for Palace Entertainment, Merlin Entertainments Group and Herschend Family Entertainment. Six Flags Entertainment Corporation is the only company to have claimed at least one finalist prize in each of the three annual assessments, with prior wins for The Great Escape (NE – 2010), Six Flags New England (NE – 2011) and Six Flags St. Louis (MW – 2011).

The Super Six recognition was created in 2010 as an output of Shoppers’ Critique International’s annual self-commissioned study of the top 65 theme and amusement park attractions (by turnstile volume) in the United States, Mexico and Canada. The study takes place between May and September and involves multiple on-site observations of each park, including evaluations of the parking lots, front end ticket purchase and gates, attractions, shows, food and beverage, and other facilities. Using a set of objective criteria, the evaluations include measurements of cleanliness, friendliness, efficiency and accuracy, among other variables. The total evaluations are scored and compared within each of six defined geographical territories.

“Cleanliness and out of this world customer service are still what drives halos in this industry,” explained Shoppers’ Critique International COO Rich Bradley. “Guests are still value conscious, particularly in recent years, but they’re willing to pay reasonable prices for being demonstratively appreciated in a well-kept park environment.”

“I love that the park is always very clean and there are always employees visible to me. This tells me the park wants to please their customers by keeping everything clean and in great shape,” explained one evaluator of Cedar Fair’s Canada’s Wonderland.

One of the evaluators of Palace Entertainment’s Dutch Wonderland commented, “I would strongly recommend Dutch Wonderland to any family, especially with smaller children up to age 12…I can’t say enough for the friendliness, and kindness of all employees that we came in contact with today in the park. It truly is a kingdom for kids.”

“I would recommend this park to my friends and family because it’s easy to navigate, the attractions are exciting and food concessions are much better than other amusement parks,” said an evaluator of Merlin Entertainment Group’s Legoland Florida. “The size of the park lets us do all of the activities in one visit. The employees working there really go out of their way to be friendly and helpful.”

“I appreciate the dress code for park visitors and the fun old style atmosphere the park provides. The rides are fun and the park is clean and well kept. There are plenty of shows for all ages and the park is well shaded to provide relief from the summer heat,” explained an evaluator of Herschend Family Entertainment’s Silver Dollar City.

An SCI evaluator of SW Winner, Sea World San Diego, said, “I was extremely impressed by the professional yet very personal service all staff provided. The shows were exceptional and entertained the adults as well as the children. The children in our party loved the kids play area of Sesame Street Bay of Play and it was great to have an area to just let them run around in between sitting down to watch shows.”

“The shows were entertaining and staggered nicely throughout the day,” commented an evaluator of Six Flags Discovery Kingdom. “The food that I ate was tasty and was served in large portions. The wait time for rides was reasonable and there were many choices available.”

The study also incorporates SCI’s Neuro-Economic Evaluations which measure subjective reactions to the evaluators’ experiences. These measurements capture present impressions as an indicator of the likelihood of a guest spinning a positive halo of their experience in the park to their sphere of influence and through social media, or as a “net promoter”. This data also highlights the factors which impact the depth of guest loyalty to the brand and the scaled likelihood of generating future revenue for the company directly and indirectly through that particular guest’s recent experience at the park.

“Overall across the nation, scores continue to remain at high marks,” continued Bradley. “When you look at the aggregate numbers from all evaluations of all parks reviewed, the areas ranking the lowest are the front end experience (parking lot/gate) and food and beverage; and most of the complaints relative to these areas involve inadequate or indifferent/unfriendly staffing…that’s why our work is so valuable to help our clients uncover, train and correct those deficiencies.”

-30-

About Shoppers’ Critique International

Shoppers’ Critique International is one of America’s largest and oldest customer intelligence companies. Based in suburban Orlando, Florida since 1972, the customer service capital of the world, SCI has developed a legacy of providing the nation’s top corporations with reliable and insightful measurement metrics, analysis and assessment and re-directional training across dozens of industries. A charter member of the Mystery Shopping Providers Association, Shoppers’ Critique captures the customer experience for its clients, delivering the highest quality, most credible information in a timely manner, as well as actionable solutions to maximize customer retention and revenue growth, providing an unparalleled return on investment.

 

MSPA-NA Selects Shoppers’ Critique COO Rich Bradley as Board Treasurer

 (Longwood, FL – November 10, 2012The Mystery Shopping Provider’s Association – North America has announced that Rich Bradley, Chief Operating Officer of suburban Orlando-based Shoppers’ Critique International, one of America’s largest and oldest customer intelligence companies, has been elected to the position of MSPA-NA Board Treasurer for the 2013 fiscal year, effective January 1. Mr. Bradley was elected by a majority vote of the trade association’s nearly 150 member corporations.

“It is a great honor to continue to serve our industry on a national basis, while engineering a tremendous transition and growth curve here over the last several years at Shoppers’ Critique,” commented Bradley. “As our economy and industry evolve, I look forward to tackling the leadership challenges and opportunities that will present themselves at our company and on an industry-wide basis.”

Bradley began serving the MSPA-NA Board in 2011 as a member of the Legislative Committee. He was formally elected to the Board of Directors and appointed Chairman of the MSPA-NA Legislative Committee in January 2012, at a time when the Obama administration was attacking the legal status of independent contractors. He plans to continue to work with the next Legislative Chair to help insure that the rights of independent contractors, the lifeblood of mystery shopping companies, are protected from improper misclassification.

Since March 2010, Bradley has served as COO of Shoppers’ Critique International, leading the company through a transition from a well-respected mystery shopping company into a fully-equipped vendor of varied customer intelligence tools. Today Shoppers’ Critique provides an array of research services, including on-site shops, video shops, phone shops, internet shops, compliance audits, exit interviews, web-receipt surveys, internet surveys, social media monitoring, focus groups and analysis, data review and employee training for hundreds of clients over dozens of industries throughout the nation and the world.

Shoppers’ Critique International became a charter member of the MSPA-NA at its inception in 1998.

-30-

About Shoppers’ Critique International

Shoppers’ Critique International is one of America’s largest and oldest customer intelligence companies. Based in suburban Orlando, Florida since 1972, the customer service capital of the world, SCI has developed a legacy of providing the nation’s top corporations with reliable and insightful measurement metrics, analysis and assessment and re-directional training across dozens of industries. A charter member of the Mystery Shopping Providers Association, Shoppers’ Critique captures the customer experience for its clients, delivering the highest quality, most credible information in a timely manner, as well as actionable solutions to maximize customer retention and revenue growth, providing an unparalleled return on investment.

Can a Mystery Shopper Company Really Improve Your Bottom Line?

Your bottom line is the amount of money you actually make after all of your expenses have been covered. That’s a simple definition but one that is accurate and applicable to this example. The answer to the question in the title is yes, a mystery shopper company can improve your bottom line. They can do this by evaluating how your company works and providing you the information you need to make it more efficient.

Go back to the simple definition again. How much do you, or more specifically does the company make “after expenses”? It’s those last two words that are the most important part of this question. Regular expenses are your overhead, manufacturing, taxes, salaries, and incidentals. Other items you can put in the expense column are human error and inefficiency. These can be eliminated by hiring a mystery shopper company.

A mystery shopper’s job is to go in to a place of business and shop, taking note of how the employees work and what consumers have to go through to make a purchase. If this process is difficult, they file a report explaining why and you as the company owner or manager can make changes to make it easier, saving you in the long run as your customers will be happier.

Streamlining the process may allow you to cut personnel, work less hours yourself, and free up your customer service personnel who currently spend all their time fielding calls and complaints. Eliminating mistakes and cutting back on unnecessary paperwork and waiting time can vastly improve productivity and therefore profit margin.

Here’s another example. Let’s say you run a call center for inbound calls. Your customers call in and have to go through a waiting period and then a series of transfers before they get to where they need to be. Some of these can be eliminated but you need to know what the process is before you can make the changes. A mystery shopper, or caller, can go through the system and report on its inefficiencies.

Regardless of what type of business you own, a mystery shopping company can help you improve your bottom line. The initial expense is well worth what you will save in the long run. Think of it as checking for leaks so you can patch the holes. Your company efficiency, no matter how good it is now, can be improved.

What??! No Shops in My Area??! Here’s Why You Might Not See a Shop.

Every so often we get a post or a question that goes something like “I live in Overland Park, KS and there are no shops in my area!” or “I used to do lots of shops for ____ in my area, I performed them well, and now I hardly get assigned them anymore…what gives?”

Fair questions…and a lot of times, you might be feeling that you have been slighted, but that’s not the case (if there has been an issue, you would know, as we would have called you to work through any past deficiencies).

So what is going on?

Well, there can be several reasons for shops drying up in a certain area…here are some of the most common:

1. The Client Has Cut Back on Shops.
Even though we appear to be sluggishly pulling out of the Great Recession, we are doing so…sluggishly! These poor economic times have caused some clients at all marketing firms to cut back on their marketing and PR dollars, including their mystery shopping programs. It could be the location you shopped was scheduled to be shopped 3 or 4 times a month in the past during better times; that has since been cut down to 1 time a month….now if there were 4 shoppers a month each taking an assignment, and now we are down to 1 hypothetically, then 3 shoppers are going to lose that assignment until better times when the client re-ups their shop volume again.

2. The Client Suspends or Ends Their Program.
Even worse than #1 above, tough times can cause one of our clients to suspend or end their program until better times, or for good. We have had clients who have filed bankruptcy or gone out of business, and so there goes their shopping program. Often, clients have personnel changes…and sometimes the decision maker who has brought their business to Shoppers’ Critique moves on, and a new person comes in and puts their stamp on the company by bringing in a new marketing firm.

3. The Client Requires Shopper Rotation.
Yes, it really is true, some clients demand unique impressions. It is not a frequent demand, but it does happen. So they may not want a shopper to shop the same location more than once a quarter or once a year! We are currently negotiating with a potential new client who will require no more than one visit per year from the same shopper…they want rotation and varied observations.

4. The Client Requires Location Rotation.
A client may have 600 hundred locations, but they are only going to shop 200 a month. So hypothetically, assume we shop Macy’s, you live in Oviedo, FL and there is a Macy’s department store there, and you can’t find Macy’s in Oviedo on the assignment list. It could be because it is not included in the current dispatch of shops for the current month, as it would appear only once every 3 months in this type of rotation. It likely appeared the month before and was completed, or it would show up in the following month (but then not again for 3 months).

5. They Have a Demographic Profile That We Must Use.
Similar to #3 above, it doesn’t happen with the majority of clients, but we always have a handful of clients who only want observations from a certain demographic, i.e. only from a certain age pool, with (or without) young children, etc. Why? Usually because the bulk of their customers fit that demographic, and they want the shopper to blend in with the majority of their other customers. We don’t have the discretion to break this rule with clients, except in rare instances of emergency shops.

6. The Client Has No Shops or Few Shops in Your Area.
Some of our clients are regional in nature, and may only be in the northeast. Some are national (or international) BUT MAY CHOOSE to only shop locations in the northeast (or a particular area they perceive as a trouble area). Some national and international companies are de-centralized to the point where each regional division selects its own marketing firm and mystery shopping program…so you can have a global or national company using 5 different mystery shopping providers at the same time, each with a different region. Finally, sometimes the client is the national/international corporation and they only are committing to shop “company-owned” locations and not franchisees; sometimes it’s the other way around, and the client is a franchisee with many locations, and so we are only doing their stores.

7. Quick Triggers!
Getting mystery shopping assignments for certain areas can be very competitive. We have hundreds of thousands of shoppers in our database who have access to our assignments. There are some areas where we have such a high concentration of secret shoppers that assignments fly off the shelf. We have some other areas of the country or around the world where we wish that were the case! But if you are in a shopper-heavy area, you may need to stay on top of our dispatch notices of new shops to get a jump on the competition. We now notify our shoppers who are on Facebook and Twitter when a load of shops will be posted in advance so they can be reminded to check the website. So keep checking here, and if you tweet, then sign up at ShopsAlert on Twitter!

So you can see, these are challenges presented today in consumer intelligence. There could be a number of reasons why a certain shop doesn’t pop up in your area, and none of them are really personal to you at all…just the way the business flows during these crazy times. If you are having trouble booking assignments in your area, please be patient and keep trying. Business is generally picking up again; companies are adding back shops and growing their programs, and new business is coming on board all the time…but, like with everything else in the economy, it is all happening at a pace slower than we would all like.

Bottom line is that we appreciate all the efforts of our mystery shoppers, and we are pleased to have you as a valuable part of our Shoppers’ Critique International family!

The Mystery of Mystery Shopping Revealed

What exactly is the mystery of mystery shopping? Retailers hire mystery shoppers all the time to evaluate their staff and see if they are performing up to standards. There are no mysteries involved in this. Call centers have difficult “customers” phone their callers and put them to the test. The only mystery with that is whether the caller is a mystery shopper or just a consumer who’s having a bad day.

Perhaps the mystery is where to find mystery shoppers. Everyone knows they exist but how do you find one to help you test your system or personnel for flaws and faults. Putting either of these under pressure will almost always tell you where there is room for improvement. If there is a crack in the dam it will spread under extreme pressure. Eventually that crack will get big enough to cause a flood. That’s where mystery shoppers can help you, by preventing the flood before it affects your customers.

Here’s another mystery. What happens after the mystery shopper comes through and performs his or her duties? Do employees get fired if their performance isn’t up to par? Knowing that, does the mystery shopper temper the tone of the final report? Is it possible that the data the company receives could be incomplete or even erroneous?

These are all questions that are asked when a retailer, call center, restaurant or any other business chooses to hire a mystery shopper. Most mystery shopping companies, in order to avoid the personal influence of one individual, will send in multiple mystery shoppers and use other testing methods to evaluate whether or not a company is functioning properly. These “control” methods ensure that the flaws are detected and then subsequently corrected to improve efficiency.

The reason that mystery shoppers have that title is because no one in the store or on the other end of the phone can know what they are. This ensures that the reactions and actions of staff members are what they normally are, not a show put on for the benefit of the customer. With that in mind, everyone has a bad day from time to time, so failing in front of a mystery shopper doesn’t mean the end of a job or career. That person and that system will be tested again if you hire the right mystery shopping company.